(Published in The Scotsman 15 March 2014)
By Rose Murray Brown MW

Liquorice and balsamic, cherries and cocoa.  The distinctive flavours and bitter-sweet taste of Amarone are adored by many who love powerful lush red wines.

Amarone tasting with Rose Murray BrownOnce a wine revered for its outstanding quality, deriving from the special dried-grape process, this special ancient wine has now become one of Italy’s most popular red wines.  Sadly, with this popularity has come a tidal wave of sub-standard Amarones as mass producers cash in on its fame.

Originally made 2,000 years ago in Roman times, from super-ripe grapes grown and air-dried on racks (the method is called Appassimento) up in the Valpolicella hills northwest of Verona.  It was a tricky winemaking process, so for centuries Amarone was sipped as a rare wine made in tiny quantities from a handful of family producers, like the Allegrini, Speri and Masi.

The best producers still use the traditional methods.  Hand-picking native Corvina and Rondinella grapes, laying individual bunches onto bamboo racks in drying lofts or into special trays in drying rooms up in the cooler hills, where they are dried for three months during which time the grapes loose about 40% of their weight enhancing the concentration and unique flavours of Amarone – before it is fermented and matured in oak.

Sandro Boscaini, who runs the Masi family winery, remembers that people only thought it was possible to make Amarone up in the cool Valpolicella hills as recently as the 1960’s.  Even in 2009 when the Italian authorities gave Amarone its revered DOCG status they sadly did not specify that it had to come from the classic (classico) hills northwest of Verona.

“What is important to realize is that it is the grape’s origin that is more important than the drying process for making quality Amarone today”, says Boscaini – locally known as Mister Amarone.

Now, today drying techniques have been modernized.  It is now easier for normal Valpolicella producers and big co-operatives with vineyards on lower lying plains to churn out quantities of cheaper versions of Amarone.

So the increase is staggering.  In the late 1990’s, 1.5 million bottles of Amarone were produced, but now it has risen to over 14 million bottles.  Now Amarone is becoming more popular than standard Valpolicella (Valpolicella production has fallen from 50 million to just 24 million bottles).

So for those looking for ‘authentic’ Amarone, the key is knowing what to look for on the label.  Firstly, look for ‘Classico’ which indicates it has come from the classic heartland of Valpolicella.

The other thing to look for is a special ‘A’ sticker on bottles.  Twelve families have formed the Amarone Family association with their own charter: Masi, Allegrini, Tedeschi, Zenato, Brigaldara, Speri, Begali, Tommasi, Nocolis, Venturini, Tenuta Sant’Antonio and Musella.  Their charter stipulates they have all been in business for over 17 years and Amarone is their prestige wine, with a minimum of 15% alcohol and 30 months maturation in wood.

What few realize is Amarone actually derived from the sweeter Recioto wine.  The Amarone style was actually created by mistake when a Recioto failed to stop fermenting resulting in a dry bitter wine which they called Amarone.

Sweeter Recioto is made in a similar way, but with longer drying of the grapes and the fermentation is stopped to ensure that the result is moderately less alcohol and sweeter taste.  It has less of the bitterness of Amarone – and as a sweet red works best with chocolate-based deserts.

Another style we are now starting to see much more of on our shelves is Ripasso.  This is another derivation of Amarone – but now producers like Masi and Allegrini are adopting more modern double fermentation techniques to freshen up this style.  So Ripasso works well as a gentle introduction to the more expensive Amarone style.

At our tasting of 16 different Amarone, Recioto and Ripasso wines these were the most popular of the wines.  Prices might seem steep for Amarone, but bear in mind the careful selection and labour-intensive painstakingly long process used to make these very special wines.
Drying Amarone grapes at Allegrini

Valpolicella Superiore Ripasso Capitel San Rocco 2011 Tedeschi
(£15.49 Great Wines Direct, Corking Wines, Strictly Wine)
Very popular for its lush ripe cherry fruits, a vibrant Valpolicella with extra mouthfeel from a very good recent vintage.

Amarone Classico 2010 Cantina di Negrar

(£18 Majestic Wine)
A well-priced entry level Amarone made in the classic heartland by a well-run co-operative: hints of cherry, soya and vanilla.

Amarone Classico 2009 Allegrini
(£55 Valvona & Crolla; Luvians; The Wine Society; Waitrose)     
This is the ‘real deal’ said our tasters.  Dark chocolate aromas, beautifully balanced fruit and acid, lush intense mouthfeel, so elegant with exotic spice, bitter sweet soya notes and a complex finish.  Allegrini are true masters in the art of Amarone.  STAR BUY
Amarone Classico Vigneto Monte Sant’Urbano 2008 Speri
(£47.50 Pipai Wines 07861063785)
Very intense, licquorice and soya notes – a single vineyard Amarone which was popular with our tasters for its depth of fruit, savoury notes and lingering finish.

Amarone Classico 2009 Zenato
(£45 Wine Direct, Hard to Find Wines)
Strikingly modern in style with more ripe upfront fruit dominating the palate, lush and juicy style.

Amarone Classico Riserva 2008 Masi
(£50 Aitken Wines, Dundee; Fountainhall Wines, Aberdeen & Stonehaven; Inverarity, Glasgow)
This was the most popular Riserva, longer aged in oak with fabulous depth, richness, balance of fruit with coffee, cocoa and oak notes and a very attractive soft tannic finish.  STAR BUY

Recioto Classico Capitel Monte Fontana 2007 Tedeschi
(£36.99 for 50 cl bt Great Wines Direct, Strictly Wine, Corking Wines)
Very cherried, sweetness very evident with fresh acid notes and moderate alcohol at 14.5%.

wine tastings

The perfect gift for the wine enthusiast in the family. Rose does In-person tastings too.

cellar advice

Rose does cellar valuations for private clients, valuations for insurers & bespoke portfolio management.

Related stories

  • January 13, 2024

    2024 will be a year in which winemakers will be aiming to achieve increased sustainability in every aspect from planting to packaging and it will also be a year in which drought issues will be top priority as water becomes scarce in key wine regions. Alternative packaging is now a key topic when it comes to sustainability with wine

  • January 6, 2024

    My pick of progressive wineries to watch in 2024: Georgia: ORI MARANI An impressive newcomer to the Georgian wine scene .  This small artisan winery in Kartli region was set up seven years ago by French-born Bastien Warskotte (pictured above) and his Georgian wife Nina Gvantseladze.  Warskotte was brought up in Champagne – and is now making premium

  • December 2, 2023

    For those who like a wine book with a difference, the new Vintage Crime by Rebecca Gibb MW (£25 University of California Press) with its potted history of wine fraud certainly fits the bill.   Author Gibb gives us a fun romp through the ages highlighting high profile wine scams and lesser-known duplicitous behaviour that has plagued wine over the